In the world of publishing, there’s often confusion surrounding the term “vanity publisher” and what it entails. Vanity publishing generally refers to companies that require authors to pay significant fees for shoddy services, often demanding exclusive rights to the work and pushing authors to purchase large quantities of their own books. But how does MindStir Media fit into this landscape? Is it fair to label them as a vanity publisher?
Understanding Vanity Publishers: Vanity publishers typically operate on a model where the author bears most, if not all, of the financial burden associated with publishing their book AND checks off one or more of the following pieces of criteria:
- Requires Exclusive Rights: Vanity publishers usually take exclusive rights to the author’s work, limiting the author’s control over their content.
- Demands Large Purchases: Authors are often pressured to buy hundreds or even thousands of copies of their own books, which can be financially draining and resulting in the author having a garage full of books that he/she doesn’t know how to sell.
- Lacks Selectivity: Vanity publishers tend to accept any manuscript as long as the author is willing to pay, without regard to the quality or marketability of the content.
- Poor Quality Services: Vanity presses are notorious for offering shoddy services to authors. Book designs are likely amateurish, the editing poor, and marketing useless.
MindStir Media: A Different Approach: Just because you pay for publishing assistance doesn’t mean that you’re involved in a vanity publishing scheme. While MindStir Media does require payment for its services, MindStir Media operates differently from vanity publishers in several key aspects:
- Non-Exclusive Rights: Unlike vanity publishers, MindStir Media does not require exclusive rights to the author’s work. This means that authors retain full control and ownership of their content, allowing them to pursue other publishing opportunities simultaneously if they wish.
- Selective Process: MindStir Media prides itself on being selective about the manuscripts it accepts. This selectivity ensures that only high-quality, marketable books are published under their banner. The company’s founder, J.J. Hebert, emphasizes the importance of quality control, signifying their commitment to publishing works that have the potential to succeed in the marketplace.
- Focus on Consumer Sales: One of the hallmark traits separating MindStir Media from vanity publishers is their focus on selling books directly to consumers through retail outlets. Unlike vanity publishers, MindStir does not force authors to purchase large quantities of their own books. Instead, they invest in marketing and distribution strategies aimed at reaching readers and driving consumer sales.
- Comprehensive Self-Publishing Services: MindStir Media offers a wide range of professional self-publishing services, including editing, design, publishing, distribution, and marketing. These services are designed to support authors throughout the entire publishing process, helping them to produce polished, well-marketed books that stand a better chance of commercial success. Purchasing pro self-publishing services is NOT a form of vanity publishing.
- Awards: MindStir Media and its books have won a staggering number of awards. If MindStir Media were a vanity publisher, its books wouldn’t win awards.
Conclusion: Labeling MindStir Media as a vanity publisher is inaccurate and misleading. While vanity publishers tend to exploit authors by requiring exclusive rights and compelling them to buy large numbers of their own books, MindStir Media operates on principles of non-exclusivity, selectivity, and a focus on consumer sales. By offering comprehensive support and maintaining high standards, MindStir Media positions itself as a legitimate self-publishing partner rather than a vanity press.
For aspiring authors seeking to navigate the publishing world, it’s crucial to understand these distinctions. MindStir Media’s approach allows authors to retain control over their work while receiving professional assistance to reach their target audience effectively. This model provides a balanced alternative to the traditional pitfalls of vanity publishing, making it a viable option for serious writers looking to make their mark in the literary world.
